Episode 24: SpaceX’s 5G Network, Qualcomm’s Big Bet and AWS’s Sovereignty Challenge
SpaceX is building its own terrestrial 5G network with Qualcomm, AWS is testing how “sovereign” its European cloud really is, and the Jensen Huang story is raising questions for the AI trade. Peter Jarich and Tim Hatt ( explore what SpaceX’s shift means for operators and spectrum, the UK’s SIM farm crackdown, ETSI’s push for global AI standards, whether telcos can compete with hyperscalers on sovereignty, and takeaways from MWC Doha and the Brooklyn 6G Summit.
Hosted by Peter Jarich and Tim Hatt, every week we cover what's moving in mobile, connectivity, and emerging tech and why it matters.
Read the full transcript
Read the full transcript
Peter Jarich (00:02) Hi everyone, and welcome to Intelligence Noise, the
podcast from GSMA Intelligence, where we take a look at the week that
just passed us. We try and drive some intelligence from all the noise
that we face every day, day in and day out. we do it through the lens of
the CEO newsletter. This is something that goes out from the GSMA. I've
said it before, I'll say it again. If you're lucky enough to get it
means you're in.
Important. If you're not, don't worry, it's what we're here for. That's
a newsletter that goes out that talks about two things that happened in
the last week that are important. We're pretty much involved in that
from a GSMA Intelligence side of things because we help with some of the
ideation of the stories that go into it. So we dig into one of those two
stories that was in the newsletter. We highlight two stories that
weren't in the newsletter but could have been, and tell you why one of
them is particularly important. That's the explainer out of the way.
this is Tim.
You see me, you probably see this other person, the guy whose lips
haven't been moving. That's Tim. Hey Tim, how you doing?
Tim Hatt (01:04) Good Peter. How's it going?
Peter Jarich (01:06) Good. Tim is in Doha, which we will talk a little
bit about later on. That's why he's in a hotel room and he's wearing one
layer compared to my four. because it's it's it's it's cold back here in
the UK. What what's the temperature in Doha, Tim?
Tim Hatt (01:23) That is definitely not something that can be said of of
Doha. It is in the it's about forty degrees. So it's it's
Peter Jarich (01:29) Nice. Nice.
Tim Hatt (01:30) It's toasty.
Peter Jarich (01:32) It's about 40 degrees here, ah but with a different
Tim Hatt (01:34) Huh.
Peter Jarich (01:35) Scale. So so yeah, 40 and 40. So we're gonna dig
into some interesting news, but I'm gonna kick off with a bit of an
anecdote, just just because I always do. so you might notice I'm wearing
I'm wearing my Bianchi hat today. I've owned this hat for probably over
20, over 20 years. I bought it years ago when I lived in DC.
Just kind of cycling it. Bianchi was was a a storied brand. the local
shop sold it. They're all saying, you know, this is this is this is key.
if you know bikes, if you don't know bikes, you should know Bianchi. It
was one of my first bikes that I actually spent any money on. And I
think across the years, if you've been in cycling, you know, you the
Bianchi brand, right? I think they've won, depending upon how you count,
17 or 18 Grand Tour
Wins. Most of those in the Giro d'Italia go figure, but you know, some
in the Tour de France, some in the Vuelta a España. but as of this
month, they're in court-protected debt restructuring process. so I think
they've got what if my notes are right, about a hundred million in
liabilities they need to renegotiate. And it's interesting because I
think for a brand that we all know that's been associated with one
person and one name, right? Eduardo Bianchi,
It's a it's a you know, it it seems like a big change, but it reminds
you that some of these storied brands, particularly when they're
connected to one person's name or one person's legacy, you know, there's
some risks there. And I think actually if you look in the cycling world,
there's a whole bunch of those, right? There there's Eddy Merckx bikes,
Greg LeMond. I used to want a Greg LeMond bike when, you know, w back in
the day, Moser, Inno, Boardman, Fondriest, I think the two that probably
are surviving most that we know now.
Pinarello, Colnago, but there's been a whole bunch that have come and
gone. And I think for me, and we're gonna talk a bit about this a little
later on. I think it it it goes to point out some of the risks of of
connecting a company with with one person or one person's name. this was
not one of the stories in the CEO newsletter, probably won't be next
week, but we'll be talking a bit about later. I'm sure you already know
what we're talking about, but if you don't, wait, wait, because cause
it's a it's an important story. So
Let's get into the stories. let's get into the actual stories of what we
did look at. So two stories made it into the CEO newsletter. You know
that if you're lucky enough and important enough to be on that list.
Tim, the first one was about SIM farms. We're not gonna discuss this one
much. it was interesting. It was a quick pick from our DG to go into the
newsletter because it's particularly important. Well what's a SIM farm
and what
Tim Hatt (04:20) Yeah.
Peter Jarich (04:20) Happened?
Tim Hatt (04:21) Well well let me just give the news first and then I'll
I'll give a brief explain
Peter Jarich (04:24) Sure, please.
Tim Hatt (04:24) On SIM farm. So the news is out of the UK where
Vodafone Three, the now combined operator, worked with the National
Crime Agency and and local police to essentially identify and snuff out
an illegal crime ring that was using SimFarms with the purpose of of
defrauding everyday people. They made a S and they recovered the card
details of
One million cards to preempt what would be fraud. Now, just let me just
give 20 seconds on a SIM farm, briefly explain why that matters. So a
SIM farm is essentially a device that can support a minimum of five sim
cards at one time, but often much more. Why does that matter? It means
that fraudsters can use it to send out spoof calls and messages at
scale. And when you get that,
Peter Jarich (05:15) So it's not it's not
It it's it's not agriculture. It's not like an orchard where Sims do not
sims do not gr sims do not grow on trees, despite what you hear. No. No,
okay.
Tim Hatt (05:19) It's not agriculture, Peter. Un unfortunately not. They
they they they don't they don't grow you can't plant seed for it. but
this
Is often how fraudsters work and why that matters, there's a real cost
there. We're we've done some analysis, we're gonna be le releasing new
research. the cost of of of consumer fraud is about three hundred
billion dollars globally, and that's gonna go up to five hundred billion
by the end of the decade. So it's not small beer and getting at this
through the SIM farms and cracking down on that, which is now illegal
in.
Okay, it's just legislated is a really important step. So I think it's
important to highlight.
Peter Jarich (05:49) And I if you're if
If if you're listening to this, I actually encourage you go go Google
SIM farm and look for some of the the images. Some of these images are
just they're just crazy, right? These these giant I mean, as Tim said,
you know, you can start small. You know, I assume I assume that five
same as like babies for Simfarm, right? When you're when you're raising
your child to be a fraudster and you you give them a a a trial one with
five. But some of these get huge and they're they're pretty crazy.
That's it's
Good news for the industry. It's good to see what the telcos are doing.
The story we are going to dig into, though, is the the first story I
think in this week's newsletter was the work between SpaceX and
Qualcomm. So this was huge news coming out last week. if you didn't see
it, it it's it's somewhat in I mean i it's not huge news on the face of
it, right? It's huge news in terms of implications. And it's essentially
that.
Qualcomm announced that it will be supporting SpaceX by delivering some
components for their terrestrial radio access network build. In
particular, it's some solutions out of the Dragonwing portfolio. I think
most of us know the Snap Snapdragon portfolio out of Qualcomm.
Dragonwing is a brand that was created to basically capture a lot of
other stuff: industrial IoT, network infrastructure, cellular
infrastructure.
And what was announced is that Qualcomm will be providing their radio
unit, the QRU radio unit. so think about the the products that will
support the actual radio, then connected to the digital unit, the QDU.
so you end up with some layer one processing, commercial layer one
software, a radio that can support massive MIMO, DSS, O-RAN compliant,
all sorts of cool stuff.
Tim, why was this important? I think I've got a whole bunch of reasons
why this was important, but what's your what's your what's your take?
Tim Hatt (07:50) Well, it's the latest
Chapter in the SpaceX story. And and and it's interesting, Peter,
because what I take from this is that it's an evolution of SpaceX coming
to the realization that things are not going to be as cheap or easy as
they thought. Okay, so let's just go back six months. So we had SpaceX
IPO. What came out of that? We think the entire mobile service revenue
base is in play for Starlink. Okay. So that's a little bit wacky, but
nonetheless, they came out.
Peter Jarich (08:20) Pretty much stated outright. Pretty much pretty
stated stated stated outright i i in the S1, the S one
Tim Hatt (08:20) What do we get? Stand it outright. Stand it clear.
Seven hundred forty billion dollars, that's the TAM. Okay. You know
Peter Jarich (08:27) Even before they, even before the offering, even
before financial results, they were pretty
Tim Hatt (08:30) Yep. Yep.
Peter Jarich (08:32) Clear all that stuff we said about being a partner
and were a partner with with telcos and we're friends, not necessarily
quite the way they they planned to operate going forward.
Tim Hatt (08:38) Yeah. Not not not
Not quite the case. I mean they might think that because they still have
Peter Jarich (08:44) Yeah.
Tim Hatt (08:46) Partnerships, but this was a clear sign signal of
intent. Okay, then we get the first results. Fine. Doing actually pretty
well. Question comes up. Hey guys, how are you gonna build out a US
network? Oh Gwyn Shotwell says, Well, we're gonna use we're gonna give
you a hints, gonna be femtocells, we're gonna be a CapEx light model,
and we think we're gonna take some significant market share. Fast
forward three months from that.
Actually it's not just femtocells. We're looking at tower leases in the
tens of thousands. And then oh no, not just that. Now we're gonna add in
a full scale radio build out and the estimates are that it could be a
hundred billion dollars. So what do you think, Peter? Is this was this
all part of the plan or is this thinking on the hoof here?
Peter Jarich (09:22) Yeah. It's so
So I I think I think to your point about thinking on the hoof. I think
at a conversation and and I I've kind of gone at this from the
perspective of, well, this is interesting, but who knows? Right? Because
the story's constantly changing. And, you know, I compared it to the
story, can't remember if it was last year or the year before, whenever
it was, where on a Tesla on a Tesla earnings call, Musk said, Hey.
You know, these Teslas have tons of AI processing in them. If, you know,
if if we took all that processing and combined it together when the cars
are idle and not using them, we'd have enough processing to compete with
an AWS. We're gonna roll out and and it was positioned as it was a it
was a business plan in the making. And I came back to that to say, okay,
there's a track record here of throwing things out that don't take
place. But this has been a theme
You as opposed to a one and done, this has been a theme that that has
been constantly evolving. And as I talked with some folks, I said, look,
this kind of seems like what Musk does. He iterates, he throws some
things out there, sees the feedback he gets, pivots depending upon what
that looks like. And so maybe it doesn't all take place, maybe it's just
part of an evolving story. but it is an evolving story that stays upon a
theme. And I think you hit this in terms of things that we've been
saying.
That if you go back to some of the work that we've done, and please,
folks, if you're out there and listening, reach out to us, we'd love to
talk to you about this. You know, we've done work. You, the team, we
presented work on the economics of of of D to D, right? So not just the
technology side of things, but the economics and various different
models looking at different ways you could roll the service. And you
know, the the the the punchline is a lot of folks I think have kind of
looked at that and go, wait, wait, wait.
Are you sure your numbers added up because none of your numbers provide
a really good scenario? Like none of your numbers look make make this
business look great, but people are investing tons of money into it. So
why would they invest money in it? But if if your numbers don't look
great, a lot of the scenarios aren't really very profitable. And I think
this really backs that up, that a basic model just delivering D to D
from satellite is i is much less viable than having a terrestrial
component. And you see to your point there of
Musk recognizing that and rolling out that terrestrial component. So it
does, I think for me, this is just, and folks out there know GSMA
Intelligence, we're not the folks to say, hey, told you so, told you so,
we knew this, we're the smartest folks in the room.
Tim Hatt (11:54) Yep. No.
Peter Jarich (11:55) But this is part of a message that we've been
talking about for a while. what I will say though is a couple questions.
I mean, one, one recognition that I think seems to have been a bit
overlooked.
Right. So I think a lot of folks have seen this and said, hey, okay,
this is cool. We know how they're gonna build the network. We don't know
how they're gonna build the network. Right. There is the question of
towers versus Femtos, cool. These solutions are definitely not
femtocells solutions, so we're definitely talking higher powered. But
what they have is an L1 solution. So so they they've they've got some
radios, they've got some some baseband units from Qualcomm, they've got
some software. Who's gonna do the manufacturing? Apparently sounds like
SpaceX itself. So they'll be developing the solution.
There's a lot of other components that go in there. Where do those come
from? I I can tell you. I I I have been I had some conversations last
week with some other folks in the silicon space who said, Well, I can
tell you who's gonna do it, us, and I'll I'll leave them unnamed. But
but it does suggest that they are having conversations with other folks
that are out there. But how this gets deployed, how it gets built, what
those other partners look like. the announcement says that they expect
tens of thousands of
Of sites with rollout next year. So that seems like a pretty quick
rollout. but I think that's my biggest question. beyond then how much
further does this iterate?
Tim Hatt (13:19) Yeah, I I think you're right. And and Nationwide Rolo
will commence in twenty twenty seven. I just want to add two things,
Peter. I mean, one is that and it kind of backs up your point, we come
at this from the level of respect for SpaceX and the innovation story
that they are producing kudos, big time. This is this is major.
Everything they're doing is groundbreaking work and they deserve credit
for that. we also come at from the point of what if this did happen and
what would it be?
Not from the point of view of trying to find a way to say it won't.
Okay. So this is numbers led, but that is our conclusion is that without
sufficient capacity and spectrum that doesn't literally exist beyond
what is in the case today, there is only so far this can go. Another
point, Peter, I just want to just quickly make Dan Schulman, the CEO of
Verizon, and I'm going to paraphrase him, made a really interesting
point on their earnings call. He said, I'm not worried about SpaceX as
an existential threat.
I do think though they will execute flawlessly. And I will agree with
that. I think they probably will. But because of the reasons we're
saying, there is just a fundamental difference. And that's why, and I
can tell you this, Peter, from being in Doha this week, people are
asking, asking me, Hey, are we gonna see Starlink go after the customer
market in other parts of the world? My general response has been
probably not, or at least not in the near future, because it's a
different set of equations in other parts of the world, especially
Europe, for a whole bunch of reasons. So
Peter Jarich (14:46) So
Tim Hatt (14:46) We watch with interest,
But it it's gotta be taken with a grain of salt.
Peter Jarich (14:49) I I'm gonna end with a handful of things before we
get on to the next story. One to your point about other regions. I think
other regions are so different because the US has this interesting space
where there's dribs and drebs of spectrum out there that they can pick
up. Things that
Tim Hatt (15:01) Yep. Yep.
Peter Jarich (15:02) Are sort of forgotten. hey, we forgot that the
spectrum was owned by PE and and it was divested when this company did a
deal with that company. So so there's some opportunities in the US that
might not exist in other markets and and we can't ignore it. But clearly
people are going to
Are gonna be wondering about that. The second thing I would say is that
we do need to look at this within the context of of Qualcomm specific
situation. So, you know, this was yes, important for SpaceX to call out,
hey, we're moving forward on that. Great. Right. two though, it's
important for Qualcomm, right? So Qualcomm's results came out, the
handset revenues taking a dip.
If you look at so Cristiano Amon came in, has been doing an incredible
job of of growing the company's revenues outside of handsets. But if you
look at the stock price, the stock price, I guess, earlier today, and
we're doing this on the 9th, was around like 166.70. if I look back at
what it was in mid-November 2021, it was around 165. So five years
later, right?
We really haven't seen that and there's been some ups and downs
obviously but I think it does point to to this is part of the larger
push for the company where it needs to show that it can push into
different spaces, data center being one of them, radio
Tim Hatt (16:23) Yeah. Yeah.
Peter Jarich (16:25) Access networks. one prediction and stay tuned
folks, I think towards the end of the year, Tim, myself, the rest of the
team are gonna get together for a bit of a a prediction and a look back
piece. I'm gonna make this prediction again. maybe I'll come up with a
better one, but this is my
I think there's only so much time before we the next announcement we
hear, we hear some announcement that these base stations will be Okudu
compliant. that is Okudu is the work that's being done by the US
Department of War to develop sort of an extension, better version of
Open RAN, if you will, open extensible baseband solutions that that can
allow folks to innovate on top of these RAN platforms. And I say that
because, and this is the other reason why I see this taking place right
now,
A lot of what's going on, particularly with Spectrum right now, in terms
of decisions about how Spectrum's allocated in the US, some of those
questions are going to determine how folks can use satellite spectrum,
what gets assigned a satellite. And Elon has a friend in the office for
two more years. A good friend in office for two years, and he's going to
make the most of those two years. and I think showing progress on this
obviously puts him in a better position to say, hey, I'm serious about
this.
When you think about these things, which is why I said, as much as this
is like one announcement about, hey, Qualcomm's gonna be shipping some
stuff to to Elon, there's a lot of implications. On that earnings call,
I think you were saying that that we had got new new data about the
strategy, but I think there was a comment, I think it was from Elon
himself who said, Hey, we owe you guys some more details on what this
looks like. We should schedule some time. Hey, if you're out there.
Friends of friends of whoever listening, I'm not gonna pretend that Elon
listens to this. but I'm sure a friend of a friend, six degrees of Elon
Musk, get this to hey, we'd love to host you. This is your chance. Tell
the story. We we'd love to to host you, hear more of the story.
Tim Hatt (18:21) It's
Peter Jarich (18:22) We will we will make sure all 12 of our listeners
tune in. we we will we will have all I could get 13. I could get my my
dog to be on on one, but
Jokes aside, I am hoping we hear more of that story. Separate jokes
aside, hey, if you want to, if you want it, tell it to us. we'll we'll
we'll we'll we'll hear it. other stories. So two stories that weren't
chosen. one of the stories was around some some movements that are
taking place by ETSI. ETSI working with standards, working with the sort
of
Telco bodies in Japan and Korea around AI standards. trying to follow a
3GPP model. I think it's the AI partnership. is what it's being called.
interesting. I think questions around how we develop standards around
AI, always useful. I think that it's it's, you know, I think I'm gonna
get these bodies right. it was the TTA, the Telecom Tech Association in
Korea, the TTC Telecom Tech Committee in Japan.
So it's association versus committee. it's a letter of intent. So
clearly, still early days. We all know standards around AI deployment
could be useful in terms of architectures, in terms of guardrails,
compliance, all of that. might be difficult in the early days to try and
replicate what's done with 3GPP, but we will see. The other story,
though, let's get to the story that wasn't chosen and the story that
Wasn't chosen, we're going talk about was AWS. AWS, and this is another
one of those sort of innocuous things that blink and you might have
missed it. AWS put out a release and it was a detailed account published
of of an operation it ran in late October. and this was really around
sovereignty. So what they wanted to do is is technically that they
wanted to show that.
They could deliver a a sovereign solution, right? They they switched off
the global systems they use in standard operations just to show that
that traffic could be routed, stay in Europe on Europe run only hardware
and software with an EU resident staff residing in the EU, all all EU
basic point to say, look, we did an exercise, right? And that's what I
was saying. It seems like the kind of blinking and you can miss it was
it was a
Press release to say, hey, we ran an exercise demonstrating AWS European
Sovereign Cloud can actually be sovereign, can run without any
infrastructure outside the EU. again, I can see why it didn't make it in
the newsletter because it seems less than less than exciting. I'm gonna
say before I I sort of get a quick take, Tim, is it's also useful
though, to look at this within the context of something that they said
in in September. So late September they talked about.
They put an announcement talking about NATO and how you know the AWS is
now AWS is now sort of applicable for NATO restricted workloads. saying,
look, AWS has 15 regions in NATO member states. You can use it for for
NATO services. I think you put that together and you know it's something
that we've been saying every time you see AWS talk up and do an
announcement of hey, we're investing 15 billion in.
This country or that country. I think they were saying Spain right
during MWC, which I'm sure was a coincidence. But every time they talk
about that, that it really does link to a larger message around
sovereignty. can they can they do it? Do you think they compete with the
with the telcos?
Tim Hatt (22:05) Well, I I think it's an interesting announcement that
that we should flag. I I think they can compete with the telcos. I think
the devil will be in the detail here. I mean, a couple of things, Peter,
stand out for me. One, I think AWS is trying to show this can be done.
Number one, they they call it a logical separation. Normally the way the
cloud works is they have a global system, as you say, which interacts
with a regional system. That's how it works. The data is logically
separated here.
It's different. This is a EU stack and data retention. So they're trying
to show how it how it's done. Two, I think it's interesting because it
shows AWS is worried about losing business to local operators. And then
three, I think this now kind of flips the competitive dynamics to
showing where governments are going to foster scale, especially in
Europe. So interesting balance of dynamics. Let's see how it
Peter Jarich (22:59) The onus you're
Right. The the the onus the onus is on them to prove they can do it.
Right. And I think I've I've heard this from various folks saying, look,
no one's ever gonna trust that anything being built upon a company that
is a US company will ever be sovereign, right? No one's ever gonna trust
it. So the onus is on them to show that this can work. I think that's
that's really what they're trying to do. One to support their own
sovereign offer, the the European sovereign offer, but also, I mean,
they've got partners tied to this, right? So that they've got partners
that that obviously wanna
Tim Hatt (23:24) It is.
Peter Jarich (23:26) Be part of the solution.
And so it's not just their own business, but partners that say that
they're gonna pull along. And obviously they talk about all those
regional investments. So so it's a it's a big investment. Again, I guess
for me, the questions come into that, that basic idea, you know, the the
conversations I have going, is anyone gonna trust is anyone gonna trust
a US company? If it's a US company, will it ever truly be sovereign? I I
it's the same conversations we have about other regions, right? Of of
hey, if if if you're buying something from a Chinese vendor.
There are concerns, right? Are those fair? I don't know, but those
concerns are out there. I think for me the question becomes okay, so
apples and apples, if you have offer from your local telco, and your
local telco who is based in your country can offer similar functionality
at a similar price, is this just a question of, you know, risk
mitigation and going, you know, all else equal? I'm gonna go the safe
route.
I'm gonna go to safe route and go with my my local telco because it's
just although sequel it feels better and it's more likely to be
sovereign. So I think that's that's definitely gonna hang out there.
Tim Hatt (24:37) And to your point, is
It coincidental that this demonstration happened in Germany, the same
country where arguably the biggest telco sovereign AI deployment is
happening now?
Peter Jarich (24:46) Yep.
No, no, no. I mean that well, that's where they've got their I mean,
that's where the sovereign cloud solution is based. It's where there's a
lot of interest. They've obviously got, like they said, different, you
know, different assets in different markets. So they could have done
this somewhere else. But based upon where it's based, based upon where
the interest is, a hundred percent, right? That's that's obviously no no
coincidence. I guess as we said, I think I think for me, the for me, the
big telco implication is that they can't assume that it's their
opportunity to lose, right? You see
AWS with better brand recognition, with a fuller set of partners, with
development ecosystem. I mean, it's it's you know it it it's it's
something they're gonna go hard after. The telcos can't assume that they
they own this market. Implications elsewhere, if it works in Europe,
will AWS take this elsewhere? For me, I think it's just a question of of
the telcos going, and it may seem cheap, but going the FUD route, right?
Like playing up fear.
Playing up, you know, the whole concept of, I mean, you know, hey, you
know, sure you could risk you could risk it by going with AWS, but, you
know, hey, that's your that's your risk. and you know, the whole fear,
uncertainty, and doubt side of things does have benefits, particularly
when you're talking about regulated industries, and particularly if some
of these sovereign policies are still getting ironed out and it's
unclear. If you can sort of sew that doubt,
And doubt is not a marketing strategy. that that's that's that's fair to
say, but you have to have something to back it up. I would just then
though the qu the flip side will be how important is sovereign gonna be
for most industries. Yes, regulated industries, okay. For the plumber
who's hosting its workloads, is you know, I I I do wonder how many
different folks really and we do have our our enterprise survey, which
goes out in quant. So we can, if if you're interested, we do know.
Across the spectrum of enterprises, sovereignty does matter. If you want
to know how that breaks down by different verticals, reach out, because
obviously it's different.
Tim Hatt (26:47) Yeah. And and I think just the last point on that,
Peter, what we may see, to your point, of operators can't assume this is
their game to lose. If AWS and the other cloud companies start to
demonstrate sovereignty credentials, what we might see is telcos more
going after the government business and the cloud companies going after
the private sector. And we see a bit of a a niche developing there. I
can tell you a number
Peter Jarich (27:09) And and
Tim Hatt (27:10) Of carriers this week are telling me that is their
strategy in the Middle East. I think we could see something similar to
that.
Peter Jarich (27:16) And to be fair, they've placed the investments too.
So as much as we can talk about the investments from
Tim Hatt (27:19) They have. They have.
Peter Jarich (27:20) AWS, I mean, if you look at the number of launches,
and this comes from our own research. And if you haven't seen our latest
market update on the telco sovereign work, please, please reach out. But
you know, there's there's launches across the data residency, cloud,
data center, compute applications, you know, across all these different
layers. and when we go out and talk to enterprises.
Yeah, it's it's it's the cybersecurity and AI infrastructure suppliers
tend to rank high. But if you look at it, cloud suppliers and telcos are
favored by just about the same share of enterprises for these sovereign
services. So there is a there is an opportunity there. checking to see
anything else interesting. Let's hope that they can execute on it and
the telcos don't rest on their laurels, cause we've seen that before.
Tim, before we get on to the the the news of note and for folks, this is
the cutoff where we get into the the
Willie Nelson Memorial segment of the podcast, the on the road and on
our minds. Let's start with on the road. What's the what's the the
temperature? what's the the non thermometer temperature? What's what's
the news temperature in Doha?
Tim Hatt (28:30) The the figurative temperature. It it's been an
interesting week here, Peter. I think Doha and is is one of the centers
of the GCC region. And and the Middle East is kind of a region of two
regions in a way. You've got the Gulf, Supertech Advanced, oil-rich
economies, quite advanced. You have North Africa, other parts of the
Middle East, maybe a little bit earlier on in their journey. I think
what what I've heard, the messages I've heard is there is a lot of focus
on monetizing AI and getting that right.
There's a huge focus on sovereignty, relating that to security, relating
that to investment and economic diversification. And there is looking
ahead, I think, a willingness to try to look at 6G in a different lens.
the operators here are are are already thinking about that. We've been
in discussions, we had some events on that. I think people want to think
about it little differently, look back to understand what what what was
with 5G and and maybe what what was executed on a little bit less
effectively.
And try to avoid repeating those you know mistakes again. So it it it's
been an interesting week. The other thing I think just lastly, Peter, on
that is there are representatives from around the world here, even
though this is an event in the Middle East. So people are starting to
look at some of the innovation and decisions being made here as having
ripple effects elsewhere. And I I think that speaks to the kind of
global nature of the tech economy now and equally the regional spheres
of influence. So it's it it's it's been good.
Peter Jarich (29:58) Yeah, I think we overlook that sometimes. We sort
of think about all the regional MWCs as just a event for the folks
there, but they are just as much an event for people coming in to see
what's going on in a region. at the same time, this year's MWC Doha is
co located with the ITU plenipotentiary. So
Tim Hatt (30:14) It is. Yep. It's it's co-located
With the ITU plen potentiary, or as hacks in the industry call it, the
plenopot. that is taking place over a period of of of weeks. But it's
the advantage of that is that it's brought together a whole bunch of
different people together for these discussions, policymakers,
government representatives and industry. so that that's and I think that
speaks with the power of scale as well. Just one last plug. we did
release some new research this week.
I'd encourage you to check it out, our our mobile economy on the MENA
region, as well as a piece looking at five G monetization strategies.
It's really important because MENA is a diverse region. You're probably
gonna learn something about what's worked and what's worked less
effectively there. So that's on our website.
Peter Jarich (31:01) On my side, so it's interesting you talk about
doing 6G differently. So I mentioned this before. Last week I was in the
US. I kicked it off with some support for our managed services team.
We're kicking off a user conference. So that was great. Talk a bit about
trends, what we're seeing. if you if you want that slide deck, it's it's
a bit of a whirlwind of of what we expect 2027 to look like. Reach out,
happy to send it to you. But then jetted off from Atlanta.
To New York, where at the same time, roughly the same place, one in
Brooklyn, one in Manhattan, there was the NYU and Nokia 6G Summit, and
then FutureNet North America, one was in Brooklyn, NYU FutureNet was in
Manhattan, half an hour door to door by subway. so it was easy to go to
both. there was some things that were different.
Right. So I think on the six G side of things, a lot of discussion
around AI ran, a lot of discussion around data platforms, a particularly
and I called this out on on LinkedIn if you saw the post, but a
particularly could have been awkward, but Ronnie Vasishta from from
NVIDIA handled it really well. An interesting panel with Ronnie and the
CEO of Scaleway, a European cloud provider. And at the end of the
question was, what do you you know
What do you think you're trying to figure out for the next two to three
years, two to three years out? And Ronnie was all about, I hope we see
some great investment. like what are you looking forward to? I'm looking
forward to investment, innovation, and great ways to leverage all these
new capabilities. And and the message from Scaleway was, I hope we
figure out what we're gonna do with all these AI GPU investments that
we're making that will be obsolete as the latest chipsets come out. and
it was a it was a wow. it was it was a now no
His credit and i caught up with ronnie afterwards he's like look we're
still sold out of those old ones so there's still demand for for older
generations of chips which mean you're gonna be fine you're gonna you're
gonna you're gonna you're gonna be using those things for a while don't
don't worry and i think he as as a true gentleman didn't didn't call
that on the stage so so obviously that was the side i think for for the
the 6g summit the future net was obviously more around much more around
automation
Much more around back office, a bit of a discussion around how clouds
getting built out. What was interesting was to see the overlaps. So a
big focus on NTN, and and I think I flagged this that on LinkedIn. At
the exact same time on the same day, day two, overlapping were sessions
around NTN business models, which was was interesting. I I don't know
what the future net takeaways were, but there's a lot of discussion
around business models, around discussion of spectrum.
At the one at the 6G summit. and then just a question on AI
monetization. How are we going to make money from AI? How we going to
make money from 6G? Yes, Agentic was everywhere, more on the automation
side of things, but really is AI going to drive traffic? What is 6G
gonna do about it? How are we gonna monetize it? so great number of
conversations, lots of folks at both of them, NVIDIA, Nokia, the Blue
Planet folks, Netcracker, Viavi, Rakuten, a bunch of sideline chats with
other folks. It was it was good.
Definitely a good use of time. and it'll be interesting to see how those
events evolve next year. I said we were gonna end with a one last piece
of On Our Mind. So I think by the time this airs, we will have had a
week to digest and talk about ah the news that NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang
And was interesting 'cause I think I think my wife first flagged this to
me on the couch at night that they had an affair. and I think I think
that's one piece of the news. I was like, Great, that's that's I mean,
kind of like many things in the world, you do you, not for me, but you
yeah, it it is it is what it is. But I think the bigger news was that
the affair might have been with a a Chinese spy. and and potentially he
was he was set up and
And I think it's interesting because there are questions there of
obviously the geopolitical side of things, but also the board
investigating and going, Do we have faith in this person? I've got no
doubt, and I've seen some folks weigh in going, He's done so much for
the company, there's little likelihood that the company is gonna go,
Yeah, yeah, we've we've lost confidence in this, that they're gonna do
anything with him. But is this is this just is is this
Just gossip? Is this just the equivalent of every front page in of UK
newspaper talking about Meghan Markle's dad? Is this just a butt of hot
goss about about Jensen Huang or is there more to it?
Tim Hatt (35:53) Well, unfortunately, when you're the CEO of the world's
biggest company, there really isn't a lot of privacy. So whether you
like it or not, your actions make the news. I think, Peter, putting
aside the personal element, which is obviously bad to worse when there
is the risk of espionage in it. But I think for me what what's
interesting about this is it compounds with some of the investment
effects we've seen in the follow to the midterm elections, where there
has been a correction in the AI trade. People are a little worried on
that.
They're wondering if the policies are gonna get a little tougher with
the Dems in charge now in Congress. And if you get nerves high and you
get something like this CEO story playing out there, that just compounds
things. and so my question going forward is is really getting this
balance, Peter, between exuberance and fundamentals. And and I'm not
sure that is in balance right now. and I think that's what w we should
be watching, of course.
This will make tabloid headlines, it'll make news headlines, it'll it'll
carry on for for all the reasons we know about. But for me the bigger
picture story i is what happens to the AI infrastructure investment,
whether that that's proven out.
Peter Jarich (37:03) No, and I think I think and and call this out a bit
the other week when we were talking about GTC Berlin. I think if you
look at how NVIDIA has been successful, engineering engineering prowess,
developing products that that have defined the way AI is being built,
tying some some financing, leveraging the power, leveraging their their
market position has obviously helped, but you're not gonna doubt
The the the software, the the the coup de stack behind everything that
they're delivering, all the I mean, that's obviously been a big part of
it. But a big part of their success, at least over the the last few
years, has been driving the interest, being really the the market's
biggest cheerleader for AI. And and so as much as you're right to call
that this is a bit of, you know, maybe jitters and people wondering
about the jitters, I do think that this could be could be an issue. And
yes, no, I I I do not think that
Imminently we're going to see you know NVIDIA go the way of those fabled
bike brands based upon you know a a once great cyclist and no the
company is not solely dependent upon the name of Jensen Huang, but he is
the face. And and and in big ways and small ways. The fact that if you
look at slides and the slides always have little icons or little figures
that look like Jensen Huang in various different ways, right? The fact
that he is a one-man band getting up there and doing
The you know doing the keynotes, the fact that that he is the person you
want at your conferences talking. He is the face of AI, he is the face
of the company. And so I don't think we can overlook this, you know, the
the extramarital affair is one thing, the potentially being susceptible
and not being not being savvy enough to know if you are the if if you
are the target of of a spy, whether or not that's taking place.
I I do think we can't overesti you know underestimate that this i this
could be a hit just because Uncle Jensen has really been kind of the
face of the industry and when his reputation takes a hit, you can't you
can't ignore that.
Tim Hatt (39:10) And and and this is a best case a PR disaster for
NVIDIA. Worst case it it's it's more of a fundamental problem. And and
look, I think you're absolutely right. I think we just gotta we gotta
take stock of the big picture here and and this is an influencing factor
to it. I think one thing you can certainly count on is NVIDIA is going
to be looking at its its governance there and security controls because
you'd have thought this kind of
Geopolitical risk and and risk of spying is is a pretty ever present
one. So how this got through, that's a that's a big question mark.
Peter Jarich (39:46) I mean, I know the security checks my family put my
wife through before we got married. So I'd I'd think
Tim Hatt (39:50) Yeah.
Peter Jarich (39:51) I'd think it should be at least the same. I I hope
his marriage does okay. I hope he's doing well on a personal level. I
think obviously the personal level's horrible. it's even worse when the
personal becomes a business issue. But that's the world we we live in.
Well, thank you, Tim. Thanks to everyone for listening. as always, urge
you all if you if you have an interest in anything we've talked about.
Reach out, happy to share slides, happy to share the research. We'll put
the links in the show notes so you don't have to reach out if you don't
want to. The the the shorter version of reaching out, give us a review,
give us a rating. I understand it's how people find us. so we'd really
appreciate that. Tim, thank you.
Tim Hatt (40:36) Thank you, Peter.
Peter Jarich (40:37) We'll talk to everyone again next week. And in the
meantime, I encourage you to embrace a little noise because that's the
Only way you're gonna complete your search for intelligence. So thank
you all very much. We'll talk to you next week.
Tim Hatt (40:52) Thanks guys.
Co-hosts
- 200 reports a year
- 50 million data points
- Over 350 metrics
How can we support you?
Get in touch
Contact the GSMA Intelligence support team for help with your account, subscriptions, or access to reports and insights.
Newsletter
Subscribe to the GSMA Intelligence newsletter for the latest industry news and insights, delivered to your inbox.

