This Report is locked

Please sign in or register for a free public account to access this report.

Learn more about our packages

There are huge inconsistencies in the way mobile operators report key performance indicators (KPIs). Every quarter, when the time comes to open the covers of operators’ well-polished earnings books, we – at GSMA Intelligence Towers – are always expecting a few disruptive changes in reporting style.

It's no secret that mobile operators do not use standard definitions for every KPI, but we have noticed that when a reporting style changes it’s often either to inflate performance or to hide underperforming activities.

Take France Telecom’s Orange as an example. Until recently, the operator group reported "personal broadband customers," which used to club together EDGE, 3G and HSPA devices. But in its Q1 2009 results, Orange started reporting "3G customers" in France, Spain, the UK and Poland. A naive analyst would therefore think that they have streamlined and backdated their previous reporting to exclude EDGE and only include WCDMA devices, but said analyst would be mistaken. In fact, the new "3G customers" figures are even more misleading and still include EDGE – in markets such as Poland or Romania, we estimated that EDGE represents a very large share of the reported total "3G customers" figures. Therefore, every quarter, we have to eliminate EDGE figures; as a standalone technology nomenclature, "3G customers" should in this case simply include WCDMA and WCDMA HSPA.

But the award for the most complex reporting style in the industry goes to Vodafone. We have recently reviewed financial and operational figures reported by the operator group that were as complex as deciphering Dan Brown’s The DaVinci Code. In 2002, Vodafone had a very particular geographical segmentation that divided Europe into three zones (northern, central and southern). Then, in 2003, central and northern Europe zones were grouped under a new northern Europe zone. Later, it started to consolidate Arcor – its fixed broadband business – within its figures for Germany. Finally, in 2008, Vodafone created new regions: Africa & Central Europe, and Asia Pacific & Middle East, and also started to break out MVNOs and visitor roaming from its service revenue figures. But the challenge really began when we tried to understand if the reported figures were representative of the group’s proportionate ownership or not (reflecting equity interest). In 2003, Vodafone reported “statutory turnover” and some proportionate figures for comparison, but from 2004 onwards it seemed as if they only reported proportionate figures. Unfortunately, it is not so simple; in its latest results, Vodafone Group is reporting proportionate revenue and customer figures for most markets, apart from India, Egypt, Vodacom and Qatar (for which it shows the total sum of operations). For instance, Vodafone Group only owns 51.58% of Vodafone Essar in India, but it reports revenue figures for the entire unit – a 100% equivalent interest - as well as customer figures at 66.98%, given it assumes the exercise of call options in this market.

In addition, this year Vodafone stopped reporting 3G devices. Our guess is that in markets such as Italy the operator has been reporting a customer loss for the last four sequential quarters, which might imply that 3G customers or devices are also declining. Its rival TIM has been following a similar downward trend and has reported a drop of 122,000 3G connections between Q2 and Q3 2009.

Russia’s VimpelCom is a great example of how mobile operators should report customer figures in highly penetrated markets. Almost two years ago, the Russian operator restated its registered cellular connections base (which includes inactive and redundant SIM cards) to report active connections. The main impact was to increase ARPU and report more realistic growth and market penetration. In contrast, Cosmote in Greece is still reporting registered connections – with large prepaid volumes and declining contract connections – which has contributed to distorted customer share and penetration close to 200%. This is the most common data clean-up policy happening around the globe, and we expect to see more operators (including Cosmote) start reporting their active customer base in 2010, especially to counter the effects of user saturation in developed countries and rapidly falling ARPU.

Authors

How to access this report

Annual subscription: Subscribe to our research modules for comprehensive access to more than 200 reports per year.

Enquire about subscription

Contact our research team

Get in touch with us to find out more about our research topics and analysis.

Contact our research team

Media

To cite our research, please see our citation policy in our Terms of Use, or contact our Media team for more information.

Learn more

Related research

The mobile churn challenge: where loyalty is lowest and four recommendations for operators

Mobile networks and connectivity
Digital consumer services
Digital Consumer

The latest consumer survey by GSMA Intelligence reveals that around one in seven mobile users changed their service provider over the previous 12 months. The main reasons for churn have stayed largely unchanged over the last five years, at the aggregate level, with value for money by far the top reason. However, variations exist between consumer segments in terms of the degree of churn and the drivers.

This report is locked

MWC Shanghai 2025: a window into the future?

5G
Artificial intelligence (AI)
Mobile networks and connectivity
Satellite and non-terrestrial networks (NTN)
Digital Consumer
IoT & Enterprise
Mobile Operators and Networks
Fixed, TV and Convergence
Spectrum

MWC Shanghai is in the books for another year, having attracted 45,000 visitors (from 12,500 companies), along with 400 exhibitors and partner groups. The numbers were up from the 2024 event by 13% and 92% respectively. This analysis highlights the key takeaways and implications from meetings, summits and announcements at the event – and in particular, whether the progress seen in China can be mapped to other regions.

This report is locked

GSMA Open Gateway: State of the Market, H1 2025

Digital industries
Mobile networks and connectivity
Mobile Operators and Networks

Representing 285 networks and almost 80% of mobile subscribers worldwide, 73 operator groups are now committed to GSMA Open Gateway. This latest research provides an update on the state of the market, recent developments, and examples of GSMA Open Gateway in action. It also offers a deep dive on supply/demand gap analysis.

This report is locked
Full access
Get full access to our research now, get in touch with us to find out more about our research topics and analysis
  • 200 reports a year
  • 50 million data points
  • Over 350 metrics